Charles E W Bean, Diaries, AWM38 3DRL 606/59/1 - September 1916 - Part 2

Conflict:
First World War, 1914–18
Subject:
  • Documents and letters
Status:
Open for review
Accession number:
RCDIG1066823
Difficulty:
5

Page 1 / 10

12 & a trinedous argument would be bookfrc recimt is bod t we have had do I Australin Away Division - and split it up amongst of others. Hughes is working hand in slove w Lloyd Georg who is also a politician & terefre crooked. and Ll. George is as anxious to force conscriptin in Conshaha as Haybes 15. He two of them must have concocted over the cable, or before Highes left England, the break up of our 3rd Dion- to the building up of which
13 Birdwood & White have sent the very best brains in the A.1.F. available - a real fine staff. We have by wondering all this time in France why it ws our divisions canot get their full reinforcements altho there were $13,000 recufts in England after all the I drafts senbup t present. The matter had bu discussed & the suppation came from England to break up the 3rd Australian Din. White wrote agst it with all his strength -as when referred to The reinfor being unnecessary.
14 ments were as far intraining forwar as the Brd Dwn hedd; and it ws a cryey pe to beak the Brd. Divn up He know what a division s However - the war Council itself decided it the 3rd Dron wt to be broken into. White manages to get the drain an it reduced to 2000 men or 4000?) & saved it from being permanent. They disband it wantet altogether He thinks the undoubted weason was that Hughes & Ll. Georg wanted to use this as an arpnict for
15 conscription and he 18 very angry because A 1s not a shayht thing to do Let Abeele Sept 10. within sound of Yores after 600 this nomin + arrived in London at this afteroon. I shd have been here baf on hour earlies if the war Office didad insist on treation us was correspts a 7 were fanknow We to it &f forcing us to havel on passports along with 44 towrists of travelling Amer. icans. I had to wait for an hour squasted in a quere between a t commercial soncone of travellero
28 16 a Red X assistant, sort my batman & any white yount Juneos subatler latest thought of the walked Oh these Britieh boat Sficials settled of the Csgton Kevilwort Hotel I shall 8 aks work ha t's holida the o 2 years, reall the first i For Mityline was instad Spital ship $11 1916 I 7e a tways deliftful Lee Fisher & old Smart to again Fisher sach a a straight friend loyat rock in 2 8 an good
17 midat of aa only mid t sea of politicians smar I warm clever able prend And old Hourse, who in spite of his cynical afectation is as warm hearted generous a fellow as any of them; & a bit of a genns. I wisjudged him once on the string of his affectation cynecim. He is ambitions but his cynecism is skin deep; & very amusng The goot has an man, too in Ander. able out not as clever I thinks still he a ast improvement on a Sellhein Te 15 Something
I was wrongtere Selleri did sa and Cal 18 to know the many administy the A.J.F in Londonhas at least brains. He is very vai - that is the chief drawback. It puts his back up against all competitors - Moore for example. Mardock - whole he hd Aushalian & right on the centre palling many of the strings told me tonight that he has no doubt break ap of the 3rd the is intentional Din possible be mentioned it to white. Mr. Loch was seeny Bonar Law after meeting of the war Council a
19 B. Law sd to him. a I may tell you a piece of news which will help your conscription campayn in Cstialia the war Council has decided to break up the 3rd Hushel. an Division #15 annecessary white asket me not to mention the subject at all in cables at prent have But I will e it out straght when the den come. It is crooked chooked it to a deceit cooke on the thshalian people I believe they wd see 1need for oconscriptin without it. What a foul
20 mess this politios The British conespondnts have obtained the leave (14 is spoken of as an order ) to wear Sam Browne Bet5. I have never worn one A Sam Browne bct as originall a bett I suppose cnvented by fen. Sir save Browne, to hold apa sword Swords are not worn nowadays But the Sam Browne (or 18 it Brown) Bett remains the Sinc qua 2ot we didn't wear Sam Brownes in Pallipoh They are utter
21 useless of expensive. but there mast have been 250 000 of tim manafactured at say 20/ each (if not. more for ficers anyfor a waste of ₤250 00 as complete &atter as if you put it on to railway truck a & lipper the truck off the End a pier into the Sea However, it is the mark of the Bistish officer from the moment he tries (to force his monstache he antil dies of senility The only time he never wears io when it he

10    12
& a tremendous argument
would be:  "Look - reinforce
recruiting is so bad tt
we have had to do
away w / 3rd Australian
Division - and split it
up amongst / others."
Hughes is working hand in
glove w Lloyd George who
is also a politician
& therefore crooked;
and bet Ll. George is as
anxious to force conscription
in Australia as Hughes
is.  The two of them must
have concocted over the
cable, or before Hughes
left England, the break
up of our 3rd Divn - to
the building up of which

 

10    13
Birdwood & White have sent
the very best brains in the
A.I.F. available - a real
fine staff.
Anywa We have bn
wondering all this time
in France why it ws our
divisions cd not get their
full reinforcements altho'
there were 13,000 reinfts
in England after all the
previous drafts sent up
to / present.  The matter
had bn discussed & the
suggestion came from England
to break up the 3rd Australian
Divn.  White wrote agst
it with all his strength
when referred to - as
being unnecessary.  The reinforcements

 

10    14
were suffice as far
forward ^in training as the 3rd Divn,
he sd;  And it ws a
crying pity to break the 3rd
Divn up.  He knows
what a division is.
However - the War
Council itself decided
tt the 3rd Divn ws to be
broken into.  White managed
to get the damage drain on
it reduced to 2000 men
-(or 4000?) & saved it
from being permanent.  They
wanted to disband it
altogether.  He thinks the
undoubted reason was
that Hughes & Ll. George
wanted to use this as
an argument for

 

10    15
Conscription, and he is
very angry because it is
not a straight thing to do.
Sept 10.  Left Abeele - within
sound of Ypres - after
6 o'c. this morning &
arrived in London at 3xx
this afternoon.  I shd have
been here half an hour
earlier if the War Office
didn't insist on treating
us War Correspts as if
we were unknown to it
& forcing us to travel on
passports along with English
tourists, & travelling Americans.
I had to wait 
for an hour squashed in a
queue between a two commercial
traveller or someone of the

 

10    16
sort, & a Red X assistant,
while my batman & any
latest joined junior subaltern
walked straight off the
boat.  Oh! these British
officials ______
Settled at the Kensington
Kenilworth Hotel.  I shall
have a week's work - &
then a week's holiday,
the first in 2 years, really.
For Mitylene was instead
of a hospital ship.
Sept 11th 1916.
It is always delightful
to see Fisher & old Smart
again.  Fisher such a
loyal friend & a straight
good man - a rock in

 

10    17
the midst of an oily muddy
sea of politicians;  Smart
a warm clever able friend.
And old Howse, who in
spite of his cynical
affectation is as warm
hearted generous a fellow
as any of them;  & a bit
of a genius.  I misjudged
him once on the strength
of his affectation of
cynicism.  He is ambitious
-but his cynicism is
skin deep;  & very amusing.
The Govt has an
able man, too, in Anderson;
but not as clever
as it thinks.  Still he's
a vast improvement on
Sellheim.  It is something

 

I was wrong here-
Selheim didnt lack brains.
C.EW.B.
10    18
to know the man administering
the A.I.F in London has
at least brains.  He is
very vain - that is the
chief drawback.  It puts
his back up against
all competitors - Moore 
for example. 
Murdoch - whole
hearted Australian &
right in the centre,
pulling many of the strings,
told me tonight that
he has no doubt
the break up of the 3rd
Divn is intentional - 
possibly he mentioned it to
White.  Murdoch was
seeing Bonar Law after
a meeting of the War council

 

10    19
& B. Law sd to him:
"I may tell you a piece
of news which will help
your conscription campaign
in Australia:  the
War Council has decided
to break up the 3rd Australian
Division."
It is unnecessary -
White asked me not to
mention the subject at
all in cables at present.
But I will tell have it out
straight when the day
come.  It is crooked crooked
crooked - it is a deceit
on the Australian people;
& I believe they wd
see / need for conscriptn
without it.  What a foul

 

10    20
mess this politics is!
The British correspondents
wear have obtained the
leave (it is spoken of as
an "order") to wear
Sam Browne Belts.  I
have never worn one.
A Sam Browne belt ws
originally a belt, I suppose
invented by old Gen. Sir Sam
Browne, to hold up a
[Sketch- see original scan.]
sword-
Swords are not
worn nowadays.
But the Sam
Browne (or is it Brown) Belt
remains the Sine qua non.
We didn't wear Sam Brownes
in Gallipoli.  They are utterly

 

10    21
useless - & expensive -
but there must have 
been 250,000 of them
manufactured at
say 20/- each (if not
more) for officers
uniform; a waste of
£250,000 as complete
& utter as if you put it
onto a railway truck
& tipped the truck off
the end of a pier into
sea.  However, it is
the mark of the British
officer from the moment he
tries to force his moustache
until he dies of senility.
The only time he never
wears it is when he is

Last edited by:
Jan BurtJan Burt
Last edited on:

Last updated: