Charles E W Bean, Diaries, AWM38 3DRL 606/44/1 - May - June 1916 - Part 3

64                                               

20

hole at Ypres in order 

to get a snap o / next 
shell The  beograph chap

wanted to  is going up

in a plane & wanted to go
over / German lines.)

I thought in my heart 

of hearts the Canadians 

wd win the tree felling. They
do more of it than we

 - or are supposed to.
But Their first team 

seemed to cut well & 
coolly 

but took about 

45-mins to fell its 3
trees ( w service axes, 

thickness of trees just under

2ft ). The 2nd Australians
were next , & cut theirs 
in fine style in 31
mins. Far more vigour

& fire than / Canadians. One

64            

21       
began to have hopes 
then. The N.Zs - all.
three Maoris ( one of them 1/2 caste 
came next: & they got 

their 3 trees down in
22 mins - the 1st Aust .

Divn made not a 

bad start but  slowed owing

to getting a tree cut on the 

dead centre - & was 

46 mins or more. The 

other two Canadian Divns
were / same or longer.
so we one easily - I mean 
the Maoris, then Anzacs

The Maoris sd before . "We
dont  care whether we win 

or lose so long as we
so long as we beat / Canadians.
The Australians won

 / log chapping & / Canadians

/ crosscut sawing .   

64            

22
The French wood men-

youngsters & old men-

gave an exhibition on some 

tiny little trees w their
antiquated axes. 

" I could do as well

with a knife & fork"  sd
an Australian looking

on , But to my mind it 

ws fine to see them-poor
feeble chaps tho the 

were. For they are all
that is left .
May 22 . Monday
we smashed up 

Radingham & Maisnel 

church spires & villages
& ruined the Chateau 

D' Hispel yesty - all

 64                 

23
Geman observation Stns or 

batter artillery positions

wh have bn lft alone so
far . They in turn at
once (9pm)shelled

 Erguinghem & Fleurbaix
church- & a  shell 

exploding in Erguinghem

hit Gellibrand in / foot 

& smashed a tendon
70yds away . He ws

hit on the tendon Achilles 
in Gallipoli: & also thro'
the chest - He will 

be away 2 weeks, I believe
He wants to take his 
leave in this way & get 
back.
This morning an
18pd gun on that 10th
Battery insisted on going
on firing ( agst / advice of

64                

24
the brigade Commander, tho'
not agt his orders) . it ws
in a cellar . A sausage

balloon ws up & naturally
saw it- for / Germans

this afternoon began to
shell / house. First

single shells- until they hit 
it: then salvo after

salvo of 5.9s - 4 at a
time. They hit the gun

3 times & smashed it 

up. 
How can our poor 

amateur gunnery compare
w tt sort of thing ?

Our Anzac Corps is

not - well served as far as 

gunnery staff goes - & never

was.  ( unlike Owen, the Brig .
General commanding the

artillery , was in the retreat 

   

64     

25

from Mous & the battle of the

Aisne - & his nerve was more

or less broken by the constant

exposure to howitzer fire without

any protection. This made him

not really suitable for Anzac -

but he  wdn't do badly if only

he had the organising capacity &

energy for the to work the artillery

of the Corps. He utterly lacks it.

And he has chosen for his

staff officer the good humoured sleepy

& lazy old Sargs; The won't

artillery headquarters here is

abt as unlike that of a good

corps staff as the gardening of

a business man house after the

day at the stock exchange resembles

the work of a nursery gardener.

They don't digest the wind &

aeroplane reports etc & send the

results out to their batteries: they

 

*He may have had good brains

CEWB

1925

 

64                   

26
do next to no intelligence work.
The divis cousl staffs are keen enough;

but, poor old hard triers , they are 
amateurs, & instead of having
a keen lively staff to help

them, they have these slack inert 

limp ineffectives .
The engineers are in the

same position . The Commander

of the Royal Engineers in any

Corps has it really in his power
here, Where they specialise
everything, & make or 
unmake a Corps defences.
We have as our C.R.E the

talkative , vain, elderly
washer - Joly de Lotbiniere
a quite inefficient commander.^x
He has gained  no ones respect 
Hy talks a lot & effects very
little. Newcome of the 2nd
Divn is worth 6 of him. His 

*His gentleness & considerations were

however, of some value in dealing with

Australians.

C.EW.B

 

64

27

Staff Major - Beauvais - is

a man who confesses he is

quite ignorant o / work in

France.

It is a puzzle to me why

Birdwood keeps these people. 

Dear old Carruthers, the D.A.

& G  m.g. is as bad in

point of inefficiency^x - but he

is such a dear old daddy

that I think his able staff-

Taylor & GIbbs- manage 

to rub along pretty well.

Griffiths of course, is a precious

possession - all the Army Coys

papers & A.I.F orders are in 

flawless form, thro' his work

& little Colemans; & White is

the brains of the General staff & 

is making the Army also -

Butler is a delightful man & a

keen intelligence officer & has a

64

28

keen helper w a good brain in

Herberton. Smythe who helps 

White, is a little man in every

way, but fairly strong; &

Kennedy, very much of an

amateur (an English Territorial)

with a spirit like a perky little

sparrow, is at least keen &

dutiful. Anzac G.S is good

especially at the top ; A. & Cp

are mediocre but get along

thanks to ability lower down;

R.E & R.A are worthless-

the xxxx by their sheer hard work

and ingenuity, will probably

make a name for Lotbiniere's

engineering, he'll leave the

line better than he found it.

But their R.A will let them

down, someday, frightfully!

 

64

29

May 23rd. Went round

arranging for delivery

of Anzac books at

the fwd divisional H.Q.

etc.

Tonight there was a

tremendous bombardment

down south of us where /

Germans have taken 1500

yds of British trenches

on the Vimy Ridge, x 3

trench mortars.

May 24th. The German

communique says tt it

ws our men who were

attacking last night. That 

they " came to know'"  o /

attack & stopped it w

their curtain of fire.

1800 copies of Anzac 

book delivers to units