General, Sir John Monash, Personal Files Book 20, 31 July - 15 August - 1918 - Part 17

Conflict:
First World War, 1914–18
Subject:
  • Documents and letters
Status:
Awaiting approval
Accession number:
RCDIG000635
Difficulty:
4

Page 1 / 10

USTRAI S i oos IRST AUSTMALIAN DIVISIONAL ARTILLERY. 14th August 1918. Diagram to show "strike" of shell and shrapnel bullets at 4000 yards. Figures are approximately correct and Diagram is in proportion. At least 25 should be added to atl figures "for service conditions". ntry claim that they approach closer than the "Possible"" positions sprobable the ue splinter a apnel "on graze" still gives bullets short of "Point of Impacte test H.E ess all con favourable to "ricochet" many rounds shrapnel Sof on gral from shrapnel is obtained with height of burst plus best of in: (no r M.P.B. go engthen bove ranges. 3.75 ydet e points A a
sa 18 Antiese ttatate 15 Nentiist 1928 Liva lanske I,/7927 howoipst For free informaton and services you can't get elsewhere Se e Z time of Earl Haigs speech or soon after, the War Battle Incident Department records throw Mttie Mght on the inci¬ VHE FIRST tme in history that dent. Participants however recalled the afair as A troops of the United States fought tollows: The 33rd Division was ordered to the Hamelsector for training soon after reaching France under British command. and units of the division were placed in the lne with simmar units of the British army, in this case Reguest:—"Wül you kindly give the facts as far Australian troop the command of the sector re¬ as you are able in connection with an incident that maining with the British. The Americans accord took place during the late war, regarding the entry ing toorders from GHO, were to go into action only of U. S. troops into the front hne, I think either inan emergency. without orders, or against orders. The late Field Hamel, which gåve its name to the sector, is Marshal Sir Douglas Haig made some mention of situated on high ground and was then in possession this during a dinner given to the American Legjon of the Germans. From it they were able to main- in Lo don last year. --F. N. s. Jox, Miiler Sta. tain observation over a broad area of the British Gar A position. The British command therefore deter¬ mined to capture Hamel in order to straighten the Reply, by Lieut. Glen R. Townsend:- The in Hnes and to deprive the enemy of its use for obser¬ cident referred to by Earl Haig in his speech to the vation. The plans were laid for an attack on the American Legion delegation in London last October early morning of July 4. When the news reached is believed to have been connected with an attack American Headquarters it was held that this was by British and Amencan troops in the Hamel not an emergency warranting the use of American sector, near Amiens, on July 4, 1918. The remark troops under British command and orders were was to the efect that "an American unit, which I issued for the withdrawal of American units in the need not speciy, joined in a not inconsiderable sector. battle without orders. I understand the incident was the cause of no Mttle anxiety and alarm among Major General George Bell, Jr., who was in com¬ al connected with it except the troops concerned. mand of the 33rd Division, withdrew most of the In an interview with newspapermen after the speech American units but found that Companies C and Eof the 131st Inf, and Companies A and Gof the the late feld marshal said that the unit he referred to was the 132nd Infantry of the 33rd Division. 132nd Inf, which were in the front Hnes could not be withdrawn without seriously disrupting the plans According tonewspaper accounts published atthe
188 ADVENTURE fortheattack. General Bell died abouta yearbefore wich general matters and ofenses under the Federal Ean Haig mentioned the incident so that his own laws. Operatives in both of the Services are ap¬ pointed under Civil Service regulations and infor¬ account is not avallable. But members of his staf assert that he felt that the situation was not as well mation about appointment and vacancies may be obtained from the Civil Service Commission, known at GHC as at his own headquarters and de cided that this wasa case where he would be justi¬ Washington, D. C. ded in interpreting orders in the spirit rather than Bayonet n the letter. In any event he disregarded the order so far as the four units mentioned above were con¬ RELIC of the days when Big Busi- cerned and permitted them to go ahead wich the 1 A nessboasted private ammies. attack as the offcers and men themselves were anxious to do. Reguest:-"I wish you would please give me the The attack was successful and Hamel was cap¬ history of a bayonet which I own. Here is the tured. The four Amencan companies participating description orratherinscriptionson it: On the blade would have inchuded about 1,000 men, and the is the number 13- im a square the jetter S, on the oficial reports show that they kost 15 killed and part which ships over the gun barrel are these: about 75 wounded. In his oficial report General Bellsaid: „The chief of the Fourth British Army on the afternoon of July 3 received orders from the British Commander in-Chief to withdraw all Ameri- can troops prior to the attack that was scheduled at 3:10 A. M. on July 4. But the four companies were in the front Hnes and in such a position thatit C- was impossible to withdraw them without calling of the attack in that sector. Accordingly the four companies participatedin the attackon the morning Theletters in the name are ah the same height. of July 4. -CARLYLE MORRIS, COlumbus, Ohio. Both the 131st and 132nd Infantry regiments were Hlinois National Guard troops. Besides test- Repls, by Mir. Robert E. Gardner:- Your bayonet ing the moral courage of the general offcer who,i is a very interesting piece. It was made by Hen¬ things had gone wrong, might have lost his com- shaw, cutler and gunsmith of Cambndge, for the mand, the incident had other interesting aspects. (Venerable) East India Company. The date 1779 It was the frst time in history troops of the United isthatof manufacture. States fought under British command. And the Queen Ehzabeth granted the East India Company acton demonstrated both the willingness and the a charter on December 31, 1599, and the company abllity of the American national army to fght and continued operations until 1858. For the protec¬ soadded greatly tothe rnorale ofthe Britishandthe tion of their trading posts the company maintained other alies. quite a military and naval force. Your bayonet was made for the Hne troops and the numerals 18 Secret Service and are, perhaps the designation of the company of regiment to which it was issued. COME general information on this mostromantic branch of the Govern. Northland Travel ment, often called "the invisible eyes JOB for intrepid men and stout and ears of the Nation. Ihearted dogs-crossmg thi-gale Reguest:- "What department does the United sweptice capshaped hke a ggantie Ach States Secret Service operate under? What are crystal, whose bleak surface harbors no the requirements for this service? Is this work game nor offers other recourse from the appointive or under Civi Service?"— rom JowEs, frightful winds than just digging in. Wilmar, Minn. Repuest- "1. Uhat, in your opinion is the long- Reply, by Lieut. Glen R. Townsend: There are est distance a sledge team might make canying twobranches of the Secret Service, or rather bureaus provisions for the entire trip? of that name in two different departments of the 2. What would be the best type of sledge to use Federal government. One isa bureau of the Treas on the ice cap in the interior of Greenland? ury Department. Its work is largely the detection and prosecution of countenfeiters but is also en¬ 3. How much, and what kind of food does a dog team eat per day? ployed in work of this nature for other activities of 4. Whatisthe besttype of cooking apparatus for the Treasury Department. sledge work where no natural fuel istobe found? A The other Secret Service is a bureau of the De suitable Mist of eats would also be much appreciated. partment of Justice. It is more correctly known,) 5. Are soup and meat tablets any use for sledge believe, as the Bureau of Investigation. It deals
Downing Street. 15th August, 1918. To deelenorl My heartiest congratulations on the magnificent exploits of the Australian Troops under your Command in the recent fighting. They have added yet further to their laurels. Of course this wants no answer but I felt that I müst send you a very brief note of most sincere congratulations and good wishes. Seneat furg Hjaltets Horp
AUSTRALIAN CORPS. Wounded Admitted to Fiold Ambulances - Operations From 6pm. 14-8- From Zoro 8-8-18 To Cam. 15-8-18 Gam. 15-8-18 FORMATION To ussios o/Rank: Offiser: p/Nanks 72 32 ist. Australian Div. 1356 1061 2nd.Australian Div. 752 1. Australian Div. 32 744 4th. Australian Div. 600 5th. Australian Div. 517 Corps Troops. Other Formations. 131 1169 25 17th.Div. Australian Toual and Tota! rrisoners of Nar Alhomen WNCOLONEL. Headquarters D.D.M.. Australian Corps. 15th. Aug. 1918. Copies to :- A.C.C. B.G.,G.S. Inf. Lureau. A.
AUSTRALIAN CORPS. Wounded Admitted to Fiold Ambulances - Operations From 6pm. 14.8.18 From Zero 8.8.18 FORMATION To 12noon 15.8.18 To 12noon15.8.18 Offisors Offiser! OlHanks J/danks 1: Australian Div. 1364 2nd. Australian Div. 1062 Srd. Australian Div. 756 14 4th. Australian Div. 754 5th. Australian Liv. 600 Corps Troops. 517 Other Formations. 140 1178 17th. Div. 27 Australian Total 2534 Grand Tota) Prisonors of Mar C Brehmnev TM VCOLONEL. Headquarters D.D..S. Australian Corps. 15th. Aug. 1918 A.C.C. Copies to : B.G.,G.S. Inf. Bureau. A.
AUSTRALIAN CORPS. Wounded Admitted to Fiold Ambulances - Operations Prom Loro From 6pm. 14.8.18 3.8.18 To õpm. FORMATIONS To õpm. 15.8.18 15.8.18 /Rarks Officers O/Ranks Officers 1 Australian Div. 1375 2nd. Australian Div. 1059 3rd. Australian Div. 757 4th. Australian Div. 28 769 5th. Australian Div. 802 Corps Troops. 526 Other Formations. 1210 17th. Div. 136 138 Australian 793. 45 Orand Tota. Ad sdag Prisoners of War noe. an OOrchoce oloust. Headquarters D.D.M.S. Australian Corps. 15th. Aug. 1918. Copies to :- A,C.C. B.G.,G.S. Inf. Lureau. A.
[5 916 Eh SBORET IssUED DowN To Drynsrows. T9. NOTES ON RECENT FIGHTING, No. 20. (IsSUED BY THE GENERAL STAFF.) In the captured documents, translations of which are attached, the German Higher Command emphasizes the lessons recently learned both in attack and defence. 1. The enemy evidently considers that his recent reverses were due to the fact that the outpost zone was often not of adequate depth and was held in too great strength; that the defence, in fact, was too rigid in character. Simhar stress is laid on the fact that" the weaker the artillery or the more incomplete the defences, the deeper should be the outpost zone. All recent experience proves that organization and distribution in depth are essential if there is to be elasticity and mobllity in the defence. (See S.S.210, Sections 8,9,10 and 11) 2. In the event of an attack on a large scale with artillery preparation, the enemny apparently considers that in some cases it may be advisable to abandon his outpost zone without nghtng. His decision, however, as to whether or not to adopt this course wil doubtless depend upon the depth of the zone, and upon the amount of room which is avallable in rear. It is clearly not generally advisable to allow an attacking force to establish itself with impunity immediately in front of the main battle position. The troops in an outpost zone muust endeavour to check the impetus of a hostile attack before it reaches the main battle position. It may be necessary to withdraw the majority of the troops from the outpost zone in order to avoid severe casualties fromn a heavy artillery bombardment, but the ultimate reoccupation of the area thus evacuated should always be kept in view. 8. The policy outlined in the Gemman document” A" necessitates consideration of the tactics which will be required to meet the enemys mnethods of defence. It is clear that while the capture of an outpost zone may sometimes present no serous difniculties, the capture of the main battle position wil entall further preparation. Surprise can then only be efected if it is possible to keep the enemy in doubt as to the actual front on which the main attack is to take place. It will probably be necessary, therefore, before launching the mnain attack, to carry out aseries of Hnnited attacks with a view to the occupation of the enemnys outpostzone on wide frontages in as many different parts of the Hne as possible. The enemy wull then be compelled to adopt one of two alternatives. He will either be obliged continually to give ground and to prepare new hnes of resistance in rear--a policy which he could not adopt indennitely— or he will be compelled to strengthen the force in occupation of his outpost zone and to accept battle in that area. Whichever course he maay adopt the result will be that he maust eventually fght in circunstances which wil pernnit of the development of a decisive attack under conditions favourable to the attacking force, holding his defences un strength with his troops exposed to the full power of the attacking artillery. 4. It is quite possible that the enemy may hinself adopt tactics simnilar to those laid down in the preceding paragraph if he should again secure the initiative. This, however, does not imply that the defensive tactics which have proved successful are faulty. An attacking force which has secured and can maintain the initiative will always be able to fnd its way eventually through any purely defensive systemn. "No natural or artifcial strength of position will itself compensate for loss of initiative when an enemy has time and hberty to manceuvre" (F.S.R., Part I, Section 107). The essential therefore, for an army which has lost the initiative and is thrown on the defensive is elasticity in its tactical arrangements to enable it to mneet the changing methods of the enemy. "In this, as uin everything else, clear tactical thinking is the deciding factor.". Defensive arrangements, which withdraw the troops from the full power of the hostile artillery, and which are based upon the maintenance of reserves for defence and counterattack, have provided the necessary elasticity to .check the enemys recent ofensive operations. The development of tactics on the lnes indicated in para 3 above would doubtless render it necessary to mnodify defensive arrangemnents to mneet the new situation The true modiñcation is,of course, the counteroffensive and,if possible, the wresting of the initiative from the enemy. We may anticipate determined eforts on the part of the Germans to employ this method against us in the future. 5. As regards offensive tactics the following points are important, and in this connection the German document" B" wil be found of interest. (a) The full exploitation of a successful attack is only possible, if commanders of all ranks are quick to avall thennselves of the opportunities aforded during the course of the battle for pressing forward the advance. The objectives allotted to formnations and units, therefore, must not be too strictly Hmnited, and all commanders should be allowed great latitude in the execution of their tasks. The troops should be directed on localities of strategical and tactical importance, often at a considerable distance in advance. Freedonn of manceuvre should not be unduly restricted by a too rigid adherence to the boundaries between the various formations and units taking part in an attack. The tendency to carry out an advance in continuous Hnes must not be alowed to crammp the movement of the troops. Nothing should be done to hamper the initiative and freedom of manceuvre of subordinate commanders, and too great rigidity of detail should be avoided in laying down the programme for the ofensive. (b) Commanders and their stads must move forward as rapidly as possible behind the attacking troops in order that they may be able to intervene effectively in the battle. The system of communicatons must be thoroughly organized. Much depends upon the accuracy of reports and the speed with which they reach their destination. FRINTED IN FRANOE BY ARMY FRINTINe ANp srArlowany saavroms
(c) Eveyyommmand bwaysrespe nsible fo te protect t oe n attack and defence. This can wis and machine guns in ord ward witht ete e eiceh tein be alokde ( Whie the advance throught he enemys outpo ctlocatio Me d defences ant srconne, other s tan ofensive operat t te ntry maust less op We ges ee re circumstances are favourable, by Mocal night attacks to gain some special tactica! The results obtained in a battle will be the developme e oral and marching power of the troops. awon dda ed by pr won with e atons are stretched must be Km eofthe atta¬ s defensive position maust all be taken into consideration in deter amgte ung the depth othen denemn n Hne ofresistand sen broken and his forces in these positio al that the adva uld be contnued with rapidity andth been defeated, it be taken of the enemys disorganization advantage should Sth of September, 1918. iaosoit. TRANSLATION OF A GERMAN DOCUMENT. THE DEFENCE OF THE OUTPOST ZONE. CG.S. OF THE FIELD ARMY. G.H.O. La/II No. 9186 Secret op. 8-7-18. inciples laid dow a/II No. 8050 Secret op, dated 25618, requie further ng as regards the apse uve battle. he enemys repeated by through duri few days. ng the la e large nun uue to unately capt ured, con that our the depth of the outpost zone is not suf has imitated our su concentration of an rtillery fre and has thereby obtained our utmost to thi nk out the correct tactical reply to r to our own; we nn he defence, it must be insisted, demands very exceptional alertness, nstant and active aissance, but nnost of al, tnats sound tactical princples should be fo maer 110 t0 220 ya r where the der de je been derakped m on betweent 8 Ge the condition he dejencer of the outpost zone and eieieie enge ker the artil yet uni the deepers or the mor oo see s allotted to the outpost zone do not require too deep a ngjorna the latter should ein the formn of patrols and posts, and piquets formed ult detach Thereal distril epth of the b troops allotted to the battle zone begins at the main fresistance,a backwardst Thei resistance" is nod pf a"main Mne ofr elconstr defence and! n open F mediate em than e such dichculties ost lne wil e This warfar und the s uce and As theraids to berepelled becom stronger wil be the me into a eeie must conforn oaus matunraly, nakes kage de h ne rnust en aradon Rehing e outpo enemy tr W ag be prepared for this, and, ding losses, n se, clear, tactical thinking is the deciding fa his, as in everything els or. Uncertainty manders and men wil know what they have to wil then disappear, and both comn re of the enemys attack therth the decis or maintained ee it ground, than to incur losse to accept this (Signed) LUDENDORFF. GENERAI GENCE), 23rd August, 1918.
La/63247. (B) TRANSLATION OF A GERMAN DOCUMENT. LESSONS DRAWN BY THE GERMAN HIGHER COMMAND FROM THE RECENT OFFENSIVES CG.S. ofthe Field An Ia/II. No. 8615. Sech 3 correctness oft id down by the Higher Comr principles for the the attach Tee ee purpose GENERAL REMARKS: COMMAND. 1 7 mand must Nre Thetime a nole, even by subordinate comme has a dec e Sa 2. It has proved possible d g the frt days of an Dende de feeden as succeeded in n able to r yto act with more Greot auccessesa . o directed to ouring units. It is for the prote to provide, from th stans maust followo ve spidly close behindt amande n dee nehe meren låbe temp connes stro nost adv stafs shoul In the battle of e uter, a close connection between the stads of the higher formations and tance than that between them and the troops is of more 4. To enable d manders to exen ds, it is necessary that sheg ger battle sector have a fronn e, only drt Hne ken by the use. and not by incre numbers of If the frst break-thre ccessful, infantry regiments will push forward on thei oun To do müdetgon ko dhe te disposal deld and even heavy artilery, i Hery acco Divisions and Co e up the remainder of the artilery and Minenwerfer attack after an artilery preparatjon on a large erpenene The infantr d artillery gladly attribute the cesses t glose co-operation at last obtained with th ster arm. The recognition ofth should ered and exploited. 5. Battle sectors must not be too rigidly adhered to, so that they become" blinkers." Co-operation between small forces (artillen nd infantry mad gg e te e h eens vreme dite , so ast ult in making attacks on a large sc y or consider The prin iple of employing the reserocs ut the points ot chich progrese is being made maust be put intop actice more than has previously been the tired infantry in the irst Hne cannot be carried out by daylght without losing dshould be avoid . Apparendy ühe autack on the Aiane on the 2uh Miay, 1918. 6. The attack achjeves its object so lon sit inttich y bosses comenderableg highe hssalwayst ion of drivin e rüee o a large nes more a Eeenten us to pass to the d nce his counter-attacks on a rge orsmall scale will not ciently prepared, onnize our forces. losses against a skiHfully con cted defence, whhe weshe It is sc ever a sstion for us of g ground ii derer 4 s shou ; we st n attack to attac and to ight mportance to the situation as a v e e e e e e ieie eie e e already proved their value should be ed: — The artülern ofensive spirit; elasticity; distribution in epth; every foot of g' ARTILLERY AND TRENOH MORTARS 7. Care taken in carrying sures, due consideration of the error of the day when utense arti wed thek value onde mnorg verarador amd age hav the utüizatior attack, after havi me initial is brought to a standstil, must not be forgotten that a really th ery prepar uires tomme and muniti dere is a tend in attacks dehivered towards the end Hensive lasting severa necessary to prepare! ity of ammun udment (see para. 4, lvance shich is progressing freely should not be delayed by weiting nition to come for the artillery the enenn a few rounds will sufñce to cause him to retreat again, especiall nmander pringing up medium Minenuerfer, 21-cm. mortars and long range kan a dad om snnallosalconcentrabo ns (Schwadenschiessen) uccess against the enen esults and has ed with ven in ee and thet made Zetam ar Tüe ve aem nust be carefully 9.The ge, on an average 0 minu e ee si beer entrelyr overon nt of atoo rigid creeping barrage hav A certain amount of control at lea¬ hmnundeation in e e e e de the advan ee aking ge eehene e e e in 10. The artüllery and trench mortars accompanying the infantry (nc Minenserfer) Asthes set, so tha remaining mass of artüllery alway at od dhge unddee ereg skort to kolow ur at least, should be uld not on the is connec most dist tobjecti e e g use of oo obserpation, the artillery wil ind excellent targets during it umns, camps, batteries, etc. which are not so carefully concealed as in trench good results have bee ned from push d. A few aing and eve kommmunikeation wiüh bal Renadre kaget ühe djunsens as wel a. i be alotted to s, as many ba Fendenher, omms adg e! air observation by aeroplanes should be fully utilized. In this respect, we he high level neces

Diagram. See original

FIRST AUSTRALIAN DIVISIONAL ARTILLERY.

14th August 1918.

Diagram to show "strike" of shell and shrapnel bullets at 4000 yards.

Figures are approximately correct and Diagram is in proportion.

At least 25% should be added to all figures "for service conditions".

Infantry claim that they approach closer than the "Possible"? positions

shown.

[*?*]It is improbable that an 18_pdr H.E., even H.E.106, will give a

dangerous splinter as far short as the shortest shrapnel bullet.

50% Shrapnel "on graze" still gives bullets short of "Point of Impact"

of shortest H.E.

Unless all conditions are favourable to "ricochet" many rounds shrapnel

at 50% on graze are wasted.

The best effect from shrapnel is obtained with height of burst ∧ of plus

10min: (normal).

If the range of shrapnel in a mixed barrage is lengthened to bring

the M.P.B. up to the M.P.I. of H.E., the barrage can be more closely

approached. Full effect will be obtained from shrapnel, including

searching and plunging effect and enfilade value, which are partially

absent in H.E.

M.P.B. of shrapnel (normal) is _

80 yds short of M.P.I. at 2000

70 yds                                 3000

60  "                                     4000

55   "                                     5000

50   "                                     6000

Therefore to bring M.P.E. of shrapnel above M.P.I. of H.E. lengthen

shrapnel range by 75 yds up to 4000 and by 50 yds at longer ranges.

On the diagram imagine each of the points B.D.E.F.G. 75 yds to the

left, then new position can be seen with regard to points A and C.

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL         RCDIG0000635*]

 

Magazine page. See Original

[*U.S.A.*]

[*Adventure magazine*]

[*15 August 1928*]

[*187*]

[*Recd per*]

[*Ewan Campbell*]

[*July / 1929*]

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL         RCDIG0000635*]

 

Magazine page. See Original

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL         RCDIG0000635*]

 

Downing Street.

15th August, 1918.

My dear General

My heartiest congratulations on the

magnificent exploits of the Australian Troops

under your Command in the recent fighting. They

have added yet further to their laurels.

Of course this wants no answer but I felt that

I must send you a very brief note of most sincere

congratulations and good wishes.

Sincerl Yours

Walter Long

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL         RCDIG0000635*]

 

AUSTRALIAN CORPS.

Wounded Admitted to Field Ambulances - Operations

                                                      From 6pm.  14-8-18                From Zero    8-8-18

FORMATION                              To       6am.   15-8-18                To       6am.  15-8-18

                                                       Officers      O/Ranks               Officers      O/Ranks    

1st.Australian Div.                            1                   32                           72               1356

2nd.Australian Div.                         -                     5                            48              1061

3rd.Australian Div.                           1                   10                            30               752

4th.Australian Div.                          -                    32                           29               744

5th.Australian Div.                           -                    2                             32               600

Corps Troops.                                   -                     7                            40                517

Other Formations.                          2                 131                             28              1169

17th.Div.                                              2                  25                              3                 27

Australian Total                                2                  81                             211             4513

Grand Total                                       6                244                           282            6226

Prisoners of War                              -                      1                             26               785

Headquarters. 

15th. Aug. 1918

CL Chapman MJ COLONEL.

D.D.M.S. Australian Corps.

Copies to :- A.C.C.

B.G. ,G.S.

Inf. Bureau.

A.

[*JM*]

[*15/8/18*]

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL         RCDIG0000635*]

 

AUSTRALIAN CORPS.

Wounded Admitted to Field Ambulances - Operations

                                                      From 6pm.   14.8.18                From Zero    8.8.18

FORMATION                              To    12noon  15.8.18                To   12noon  15.8.18

                                                       Officers      O/Ranks               Officers      O/Ranks    

1st.Australian Div.                            1                   40                           72               1364

2nd.Australian Div.                         -                     6                            48              1062 

3rd.Australian Div.                           1                   14                            30               756

4th.Australian Div.                          -                    42                           29                754

5th.Australian Div.                           -                    2                             32                600

Corps Troops.                                   -                     7                            40                517

Other Formations.                          2                 140                           28                1178

17th.Div.                                              2                  25                              3                  27

Australian Total                                2                 104                           211              4536

Grand Total                                       6                 276                          282             6258

Prisoners of War                              -                      1                             26               785

Headquarters.       

15th. Aug. 1918        

CL Chapman Mj for COLONEL.

D.D.M.S. Australian Corps.

Copies to :- A.C.C.

B.G. ,G.S.

Inf. Bureau.

A.

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL         RCDIG0000635*]

 

AUSTRALIAN CORPS.

Wounded Admitted to Field Ambulances - Operations

                                                      From 6pm.   14.8.18                From Zero     8.8.18

FORMATION                              To       6pm.   15.8.18                To       6pm.   15.8.18

                                                       Officers      O/Ranks               Officers      O/Ranks    

1st. Australian Div.                            1                   51                           72               1375

2nd. Australian Div.                         -                    13                           48              1059 

3rd. Australian Div.                           1                   15                            30               757

4th. Australian Div.                          -                    57                           29               769

5th. Australian Div.                           -                    4                            32               602

Corps Troops.                                   -                    16                            40               526

Other Formations.                          4                 172                            30              1210

17th.Div.                                             10                136                             11                 138

Australian Total                                2                 140                           211              4572

Grand Total                                      16                464                          292              6446

Prisoners of War                              -                      2                            26                786

Headquarters.       

15th. Aug. 1918        

CL Chapman Mj for COLONEL.

D.D.M.S. Australian Corps.

Copies to :- A.C.C.

B.G. ,G.S.

Inf. Bureau.

A.

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL         RCDIG0000635*]

 

[*15/8/18*]

[*GOC*]

SECRET.

ISSUED DOWN TO DIVISIONS.

T/9.

NOTES ON RECENT FIGHTING, NO. 20.

(ISSUED BY THE GENERAL STAFF.)

In the captured documents, translations of which are attached, the German Higher Command

emphasizes the lessons recently learned both in attack and defence.

1. The enemy evidently considers that his recent reverses were due to the fact that the outpost

zone was often not of adequate depth and was held in too great strength; that the defence, in fact,

was too rigid in character. Similar stress is laid on the fact that "the weaker the artillery or the

more incomplete the defences, the deeper should be the outpost zone."

All recent experience proves that organization and distribution in depth are essential if there is

to be elasticity and mobility in the defence. (See S.S. 210, Sections 8, 9, 10 and 11.)

2. In the event of an attack on a large scale with artillery preparation, the enemy apparently

considers that in some cases it may be advisable to abandon his outpost zone without fighting. His

decision, however, as to whether or not to adopt this course will doubtless depend upon the depth of

the zone, and upon the amount of room which is available in rear. It is clearly. not generally

advisable to allow an attacking force to establish itself with impunity immediately in front of the

main battle position. The troops in an outpost zone must endeavour to check the impetus of a

hostile attack before it reaches the main battle position. It may be necessary to withdraw the

majority of the troops from the outpost zone in order to avoid severe casualties from a heavy

artillery bombardment, but the ultimate reoccupation of the area thus evacuated should always be

kept in view.

3. The policy outlined in the German document "A" necessitates consideration of the tactics

which will be required to meet the enemy's methods of defence. It is clear that while the capture

of an outpost zone may sometimes present no serious difficulties, the capture of the main

battle position will entail further preparation. Surprise can then only be effected if it is

possible to keep the enemy in doubt as to the actual front on which the main attack is to

take place. It will probably be necessary, therefore, before launching the main attack, to carry out

a series of limited attacks with a view to the occupation of the enemy's outpost zone on wide frontages

in as many different parts of the line as possible. The enemy will then be compelled to adopt one

of two alternatives. He will either be obliged continually to give ground and to prepare new lines

of resistance in rear - a policy which he could not adopt indefinitely - or he will be compelled to

strengthen the force in occupation of his outpost zone and accept battle in that area. Whichever

course he may adopt, the result will be that he must eventually fight in circumstances which will

permit the development of decisive attack under conditions favourable to the attacking force,

holding his defences in strength with his troops exposed to the full power of the attacking artillery.

4. It is quite possible that the enemy may himself adopt tactics similar to those laid down in

the preceding paragraph if he should again secure the initiative. This, however, does not imply

that the defensive tactics which have proved successful are faulty. An attacking force which has

secured and can maintain the initiative will always be able to find its way eventually through any

purely defensive system. "No natural or artificial strength of position will itself compensate for

loss of initiative when an enemy has time to liberty and manoeuvre" (F.S.R., Part I., Section 107).

The essential, therefore, for an army which has lost the initiative and is thrown on the defensive is

elasticity in its tactical arrangements to enable it to meet the changing methods of the enemy. "In

this, as in everything else, clear tactical thinking is the deciding factor." Defensive arrangements,

which withdraw the troops from the full power of the hostile artillery, and which are based upon the

maintenance of reserves for defence and counter-attack, have provided the necessary elasticity to

check the enemy's recent offensive operations. The development of tactics on the lines indicated

in para. 3 above would doubtless render it necessary to modify defensive arrangements to meet the

new situation. The true modification is, of course, the counter-offensive and, if possible, the wresting

of the initiative from the enemy. We may anticipate determined efforts on the part of the Germans

to employ this method against us in the future.

5. As regards offensive tactics the following points are important, and in this connection the

German document "B" will be found of interest.

(a) The full exploitation of a successful attack is only possible, if commanders of all

ranks are quick to avail themselves of the opportunities afforded during the course of the

battle for pressing forward the advance. The objectives allotted to formations and units,

therefore, must not be too strictly limited, and all commanders should be allowed great

latitude in the execution of their tasks. The troops should be directed on localities of

strategical and tactical importance, often at a considerable distance in advance. Freedom

of manoeuvre should not be unduly restricted by a too rigid adherence to the boundaries

between the various formations and units taking part in an attack. The tendency to carry

out an advance in continuous lines must not be allowed to cramp the movement of the

troops. Nothing should be done to hamper the initiative and freedom of manoeuvre of

subordinate commanders, and too great rigidity of detail should be avoided in laying down

the programme for the offensive.

(b) Commanders and their staffs must move forward as rapidly as possible behind the

attacking troops in order that they may be able to intervene effectively in the battle. The

system of communications must be thoroughly organized. Much depends upon the

accuracy of reports and the speed with which they reach their destination.

PRINTED IN FRANCE BY ARMY PRINTING AND STATIONERY SERVICES.

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL         RCDIG0000635*]

 

(c) Every commander is always responsible for the immediate protection of his flanks.

At the same time, in order to develop a success, it will often be necessary, especially

in the earlier stages of an attack, for a unit to push forward when the advance of the unit

on its flank has been brought to a standstill. The attack must be pressed relentlessly at

points where the enemy's resistance is weak. Reserves should be employed where progress

is being made and not in places where the attack has been checked. A commander, therefore,

should not hesitate to continue the advance merely because he is uncertain as to the

situation on his flank. The flanks of the leading units must be protected by the action of

the units in rear. "It is the duty of the commander to provide, from the rear, for the

protection of his flanks." This should be practicable so long as the attacking force is distributed

in depth.

(d) Economy of force is necessary both in attack and defence. This can be effected

by utilizing to its full extent the fire power of Lewis and machine guns in order to reduce

the number of rifles employed in the firing line.

(e) A few guns, pushed well forward with the infantry, may materially assist the

advance in its earlier stages. The guns should be used to break down the resistance of

strong points which may check the attacking troops and to engage the enemy's reinforcements.

As the stability of the defence increases, however, and if the advance is temporarily

checked, a greater weight of artillery will be required to support the infantry attack. It

will then be advisable to withdraw the guns from the infantry and to regroup them under

the orders of the artillery commander in order to facilitate control and to ensure

the necessary co-ordination of the tasks which will be allotted to the artillery.

(f) While the advance through the enemy's outpost zone is in progress, it is only

possible to ascertain the exact location of the enemy's defended localities and machine gun

positions by the proper use of advanced guards. When once these positions have been

discovered, the usual enveloping tactics can be employed. Tanks should not be called upon

until the preliminary reconnaissance has been completed.

(g) When organized defences have to be overcome, the infantry will require as full a

measure of assistance as it is practicable for the other arms to provide. The idea must

not be allowed to gain ground, however, that an offensive operation is impossible without

a barrage of great density or without the co-operation of tanks. To achieve success in

battle, our infantry must beat the enemy's infantry. Artillery, tanks, etc., exist to assist

the infantry to that end. The infantry must never for a moment be permitted to consider

that it exists to follow up a barrage or to accompany a " tank attack." When, after the

more or less open fighting which follows the first penetration of the enemy's organized

defences, resistance begins to stiffen again and the defence begins to increase in stability,

it is probable that the attacking infantry will often be required to push forward with a much

reduced measure of support from its assistant arms. In such cases opportunities for

making progress by night operations must be looked for and seized, e.g., by night advances

to cross exposed ground, or to surround or penetrate between centres of resistance; or,

where circumstances are favourable, by local night attacks to gain some special tactical

locality.

(h) The results obtained in battle will be in direct proportion to the efficiency of the

previous training of the troops. A high standard of training is required for success in

offensive action. Such training must aim at the development of the tactical knowledge

and initiative of all commanders, and of the moral and marching power of the troops.

6. The formation of a salient as the result of initial penetration must be followed by prompt

and vigorous blows on the flanks of the salient. Continued pressure in one direction without a

corresponding extension of base must result in lack of manœuvring space and ever-increasing

difficulty of communications, leading more and more rapidly as the advance proceeds to the

weakening and disorganization of the attacking troops. Quite weak forces will eventually check

the advanced guards of an army of which the communications are stretched to breaking point.

It follows that objectives must be limited, but not too closely limited. The maintenance of

communications, the endurance of the attacking troops, the strength of the enemy's forces and the

organization of his defensive position must all be taken into consideration in determining the depth

of the objectives.

When the enemy's main line of resistance has been broken and his forces in these positions have

been defeated, it is essential that the advance should be continued with rapidity and that every

advantage should be taken of the enemy's disorganization.

6th of September, 1918

2

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL*]

Ia/53917.

(A.)

TRANSLATION OF A GERMAN

DOCUMENT.

THE DEFENCE OF THE OUTPOST ZONE.

C.G.S. OF THE FIELD ARMY.           G.H.Q.

Ia/II No. 9135 Secret op.                   6-7-18.

The principles laid down in Ia/ll No. 8950 Secret op., dated 25-6-18, require further

supplementing as regards the defensive battle.

The enemy's repeated breaks-through during the last few days, and the large number of

prisoners which he has thus unfortunately captured, continue to demonstrate that our forward

defence is too dense and that the depth of the outpost zone is not sufficient.

The enemy has imitated our surprise concentration of artillery fire and has thereby obtained

successes similar to our own; we must do our utmost to think out the correct tactical reply to

this.

The defence, it must be insisted, demands very exceptional alertness, and constant and active

reconnaissance, but most of all, that sound tactical principles should be followed.

Outpost zones from 110 to 220 yards in depth do not suffice; they are only permissible if our

positions are strongly organized and if very strong artillery support is available. They must be

deeper, i.e., 550 to 1,100 yards or more, especially where the position has not yet been developed

and the available artillery is weak.

The relation between the depth of the outpost zone and the condition of the defences and

the artillery strength is not yet universally realized. The weaker the artillery, or the more incomplete

the defences, the deeper should be the outpost zone.

The troops allotted to the outpost zone do not require too deep a fighting formation; the latter

should be more in the form of patrols and posts, and piquets formed of assault detachments.

The real distribution in depth of the battle troops allotted to the battle zone begins at the main

line of resistance, and extends backwards from it.

The idea of a "main line of resistance" is not peculiar to a well-constructed position. Such

a line forms part of every systematic defence and must be clearly defined on the ground; it is true

that this is easier to do in a trench system than in open fighting immediately after an attack. It

is the special duty of all commanders to overcome such difficulties.

The outpost line will be supported by fire from the main line of resistance. Rifles, light

and heavy machine gun companies and light " Minenwerfer," and batteries detailed to protect

the outpost zone must be systematically employed for this purpose. In addition, assault detachments

may be sent forward from the main line of resistance. It is then possible to carry on an

active outpost warfare of minor engagements. This warfare does not differ from an attack against

hostile nests, in which it is necessary to work round the strong points, supported to a greater or

less extent by fire from the main line of resistance and from the artillery concerned.

As the raids to be repelled become heavier, the stronger will be the supporting fire from the

main line of resistance, and still more artillery will come into action, bringing annihilating fire to

bear upon the enemy who has penetrated into the outpost zone; barrage fire will never be

sufficiently effective for this purpose, especially when our own artillery is weak. The artillery must

follow the fluctuations of the battle, and its fire must conform rapidly to the movements of the

infantry. Such a system of defence naturally makes large demands upon the training of the

troops, particularly the infantry and artillery.

In an attack with systematic artillery preparation, fighting for the outpost zone must equally

systematically be refused. The zone must be abandoned. Later on, perhaps, it may be necessary

to establish a new main line of resistance should our annihilating fire not prevent the enemy from

establishing himself in the outpost zone and should our assault detachments fail to turn him out

of it. We lose ground, it is true. The fear that the Entente Powers might drive us many kilometres

farther back is not justified; they are just as hard up for men for such attacks as we are.

We should rejoice when the Entente troops attack; they generally do so in dense lines. A more

favourable opportunity for adding to their losses is hardly to be hoped for. The Higher Command

and regimental officers and men must be prepared for this, and, avoiding losses, must stand to

meet the enemy.

In this, as in everything else, clear, tactical thinking is the deciding factor. Uncertainty

will then disappear, and both commanders and men will know what they have to do.

If there is any doubt as to the nature of the enemy's attack, and as to whether the garrison

of the outpost zone should be withdrawn or maintained, the decision should be to withdraw it. It

is always better to accept this loss of ground, than to incur losses by an unnecessary defence of the outpost zone.

(Signed) LUDENDORFF.

GENERAL STAFF (INTELLIGENCE),

GENERAL HEADQUARTERS.

23rd August, 1918

3

[*RCDIG0000635*]

 

Ia/53247.

(B.)

TRANSLATION OF A GERMAN

DOCUMENT.

LESSONS DRAWN BY THE GERMAN HIGHER COMMAND

FROM THE RECENT OFFENSIVES.

C.G.S. of the Field Army.  G.H.Q.,

Ia/II. No. 8,615. Secret op.  9-6-18.

The correctness of the guiding principles laid down by the Higher Command for the training

of the troops and the methods of the attack has been confirmed in the smallest detail by the

"Blucher"* offensive. Certain fresh points of view, which must be borne in mind for

purposes of training, call for the following observations: —

GENERAL REMARKS: COMMAND.

1. The command must keep the troops well in hand, but without hampering their impulse to

press forward on their own initiative. To secure this, greater importance should be attached to the

preparation of means of communication for the transmission of information, to reports being sent

back, and to the arrangements for keeping in mutual touch. The time which orders and reports

take to reach their destination must be taken into consideration. A quick grasp of the situation

as a whole, even by subordinate commanders, has a decisive influence on the success of

the operations.

2. It has proved possible during the first days of an offensive to neglect the question of

protecting the flanks. If one unit has succeeded in penetrating the front deeply at one point,

the neighbouring units have speedily been able to recover their alignment (see also para. 5).

As the resistance became stronger, it was necessary to act with more caution. Generally speaking,

too much boldness is less dangerous than too much caution. Great successes are only obtained by

driving the attack home without any other consideration. Consequently, objectives should not be

too limited and attention should not be too anxiously directed towards neighbouring units. It is

the duty of the commander to provide, from the rear, for the protection of his flanks.

3. If rapid progress is made, staffs must follow very rapidly close behind the troops, so that

no opportunity is lost, and the commander can decide at the right moment whether a combined

attack is necessary or whether it is a question of pursuit actions, which regimental commanders

must carry out on their own initiative (the divisional staff should be temporarily 2-3 kilometres

behind the most advanced infantry). When the resistance becomes stronger, staffs should drop

farther back.

In the battle of encounter, a close connection between the staffs of the higher formations and

the troops is of more importance than that between them and the rear.

4. To enable divisional commanders to exercise their commands, it is necessary that the

battle sector of each division should have a front of 2½—3 kilometres or more. As a general

rule, only two regiments should be employed in the first line in each sector. If the infantry

attack is carried out in really thin formation, as a machine gun attack supported by the artillery

accompanying the infantry, etc., experience has shown that it will have sufficient fighting force.

Attacks in denser formation will only lead to heavier losses. Where the resistance is more

obstinate, it should be broken by the use of more artillery, and not by increasing the numbers of

infantry engaged.

If the first break-through is successful, infantry regiments will push forward on their own

initiative. To do this, they must have at their immediate disposal field and even heavy artillery,

in addition to the artillery accompanying the infantry.

Divisions and Corps will arrange to move up the remainder of the artillery and Minenwerfer

in such a way as to be able to make a combined attack after an artillery preparation on a large

scale at the points where resistance is experienced.

The infantry and artillery gladly attribute their successes to the close co-operation at last

obtained with the sister arm. The recognition of this fact should be fostered and exploited.

5. Battle sectors must not be too rigidly adhered to, so that they become " blinkers."

Co-operation between quite small forces (artillery and infantry), the utilization of an unused

road of a neighbouring formation, passing by points of resistance, and the employment of the artillery,

etc., of one division in a neighbouring one's sector, so as to attack the enemy's flank, will often

result in making attacks on a large scale unnecessary or considerably easier.

The principle of employing the reserves at the points at which progress is being made must

be put into practice more than has previously been the case.

The relief of tired infantry in the first line cannot be carried out by daylight without losing

valuable time, and should be avoided.

* Apparently the attack on the Aisne on the 27th May, 1918.

4

[*AUSTRALIAN WAR MEMORIAL*]

6. The attack achieves its object so long as it inflicts on the enemy losses considerably higher

than our own. This is always the case in the first phases of a successful surprise attack. It is,

therefore, a question of driving an attack home without being influenced by the fear of losses, but

also without losing sight of the necessity for fire support and preparation by fire. It is the duty of

the Higher Command to decide on the moment when the effect of the enemy's reserves is beginning

to be felt strongly. Attacks must then gradually begin to be delivered in a more methodical

manner; the necessity for intense artillery preparations, involving a large expenditure of

ammunition, becomes more and more frequent (see para. 7), until the moment arrives when it is

better for us to pass to the defensive.

The enemy, since his counter-attacks on a large or small scale will not be sufficiently prepared,

will sustain heavy losses against a skilfully conducted defence, while we shall economize our forces.

It is scarcely ever a question for us of gaining ground at any cost. We must destroy the

enemy but save our own strength. Our tactical views should be clearer in this matter; we still

show a tendency during the last days of an attack to attack with insufficient forces and to fight

for the possession of ground which is of no importance to the situation as a whole. When on the defensive, the principles which have already proved their value should be

applied:- The artillery and infantry should maintain an offensive spirit; elasticity; distribution in

depth; every foot of ground should not be contested.

ARTILLERY AND TRENCH MORTARS.

7. Care taken in carrying out the preparatory artillery measures, due consideration of the

error of the day when firing, the employment of gas, a short but intense artillery preparation and

the utilization of a slow, creeping barrage have all proved their value once more.

If the attack, after having gained some initial success, is brought to a standstill, it must not

be forgotten that a really thorough artillery preparation requires time and ammunition.

There is a tendency, in attacks delivered towards the end of an offensive lasting several days,

to underestimate the quantity of ammunition and the length of time necessary to prepare for and

carry out a successful bombardment (see para. 4, last sub-para. but one).

On the other hand, an advance which is progressing freely should not be delayed by waiting

for the artillery and its ammunition to come up.

If the enemy is on the run, a few rounds will suffice to cause him to retreat again, especially

if a commander has succeeded in bringing up medium Minenwerfer, 21-cm. mortars and long range

guns.

8. Gas, employed in small local concentrations (Schwadenschiessen), has produced excellent

results and has also been employed with great success against the enemy's infantry at the closest

possible range, and even in the creeping barrage itself, if the wind is favourable. Blue Cross gas

shell are now frequently employed even in open warfare against the machine guns, and the batteries

accompanying the infantry carry them too. Mistakes are, however, often made in this

connection. The peculiarities of the various types of gas and their known effect must be carefully

considered.

9. The slow pace of the creeping barrage, on an average 40-50 minutes per kilometre,

inclusive of longer halts on lines where the resistance is strong, has answered expectations. The

concentration of fire on the lines of resistance has proved effective. The dangers arising from the

employment of a too rigid creeping barrage have not yet been entirely overcome.

A certain amount of control at least must be attained over the advance of the barrage by

improving the means of communication in case everything does not run according to plan. Where

the attack is making good progress, the infantry should not be kept back too much. The uniform

progress of the barrage along the whole front of the Army is of minor importance.

10. The artillery and trench mortars accompanying the infantry (including the medium

Minenwerfer) have again given very good results. As the surprise succeeded completely, they were

not employed everywhere at the moment when the enemy's lines were penetrated. It is, nevertheless,

recommended that they should be pushed well forward from the outset, so that they can be

employed immediately in mastering the shell hole area.

11. The remaining mass of artillery always made every effort to follow up rapidly, so as to

assist the infantry in its advance. Part of the batteries, at least, should begin their change of

position very early. The change should not be delayed on the ground that all the guns engaged

in placing the creeping barrage can fire beyond the most distant objectives. In this connection it

is also advisable to limit the ranges at which the guns are used, as, at extreme ranges, the figures

of the range tables with regard to range, and dispersion are not always accurate, in spite of the care

taken to take atmospheric conditions into account.

12. By making use of air observation, the artillery will find excellent targets during its

advance, such as columns, camps, batteries, etc., which are not so carefully concealed as in trench warfare.

Very good results have been obtained from pushing balloons very far forward. A few single

batteries (known as "Ballonbatterien" and consisting of heavy field howitzers, 10-cm. and even

13-cm. guns) remained continually in direct communication with balloons detailed for this purpose,

so that they were able to fire immediately on any remunerative target which was observed. To

carry out such tasks, as many balloons as possible should be allotted to the divisions, as well as

heavy long-range flat-trajectory guns, as early as possible.

In the same way, air observation by aeroplanes should be fully utilized. In this respect, we

have not yet reached the high level necessary.

5

[*RCDIG0000635*]

Last edited by:
Sam scottSam scott
Last edited on:

Last updated: